The Top MLB Catchers of 2024: Valuable Players Who Deserve Recognition In 2025

 Catchers are often considered the backbone of a baseball team. They control the game behind the plate, manage the pitching staff, and in many cases, provide crucial offense. Last year’s crop of catchers in Major League Baseball was exceptional, showcasing both defensive brilliance and offensive power. Among the many names, a few players truly stood out. Let’s dive into the top catchers from the 2024 MLB season who deserve recognition.

Here is a link to Fanduel recommendation If you haven't joined! You get a bonus and so will I. Join me my fanduel username is evenjimmysjealous. I can't wait for opening day.

Get Your Daily Weather Report From Roto-Wire Click Here Make Sure You Bookmark The Roto Wire Weather Report Free Before You Bet.

Here is a Super Important Site You Should Bookmark MLB Injury report! It's important to check the weather and the injury report, and make sure your player is in the starting lineup! If you disregard any of these your almost certain to lose money. 

1. Cal Raleigh (SEA) *One Of My Favorite Players*

• Games Played: 153 | At-Bats: 546 | Hits: 120 | Home Runs: 34 | RBIs: 100 | Batting Average: .220
• Slugging Percentage: .436 | OPS: .748

Cal Raleigh of the Seattle Mariners had an outstanding year both offensively and defensively. His 34 home runs were among the best for catchers last season, and his ability to drive in 100 RBIs showcased his importance in the middle of the Mariners’ lineup. While his batting average was lower than some, his power and clutch hitting made him one of the top catchers of 2024.

2. Shea Langeliers (OAK)

• Games Played: 137 | At-Bats: 482 | Hits: 108 | Home Runs: 29 | RBIs: 80 | Batting Average: .224
• Slugging Percentage: .450 | OPS: .738

Shea Langeliers was another breakout star in 2024, playing a significant role for the Oakland Athletics. His 29 home runs and 80 RBIs were crucial for a team rebuilding. Though his average was on the lower side, Langeliers' power numbers are what set him apart. His ability to get on base and hit for power kept opposing pitchers on edge.

3. Salvador Pérez (KC)

• Games Played: 158 | At-Bats: 590 | Hits: 160 | Home Runs: 27 | RBIs: 104 | Batting Average: .271
• Slugging Percentage: .456 | OPS: .786

Salvador Pérez is a veteran catcher who continues to perform at an elite level. His 27 home runs and 104 RBIs were among the best for catchers last season. Pérez's leadership behind the plate and consistent bat make him one of the most valuable players on the Kansas City Royals and in the league as a whole. His durability (158 games played) also speaks volumes about his reliability.

4. William Contreras (MIL)

• Games Played: 155 | At-Bats: 595 | Hits: 167 | Home Runs: 23 | RBIs: 92 | Batting Average: .281
• Slugging Percentage: .466 | OPS: .831

William Contreras was one of the top all-around catchers in 2024. His .281 batting average, 23 home runs, and 92 RBIs helped the Milwaukee Brewers stay competitive throughout the season. Contreras’ high OPS of .831 illustrates his ability to be both a contact hitter and a slugger, making him a well-rounded offensive contributor.

5. Ryan Jeffers (MIN)

• Games Played: 122 | At-Bats: 412 | Hits: 93 | Home Runs: 21 | RBIs: 64 | Batting Average: .226
• Slugging Percentage: .432 | OPS: .732

Ryan Jeffers may not have the flashiest statistics, but he proved to be an important part of the Minnesota Twins lineup in 2024. With 21 home runs and a .432 slugging percentage, Jeffers provided solid power while maintaining a respectable OPS of .732. His defensive ability behind the plate also makes him a crucial part of the Twins’ roster.

6. Logan O'Hoppe (LAA)

• Games Played: 136 | At-Bats: 479 | Hits: 117 | Home Runs: 20 | RBIs: 56 | Batting Average: .244
• Slugging Percentage: .409 | OPS: .712

Logan O'Hoppe made waves with the Los Angeles Angels in 2024. His 20 home runs and solid offensive numbers made him an important piece for a team that struggled to find consistent production outside of their superstars. O'Hoppe’s ability to hit for power from the catcher position makes him an exciting young player to watch in the coming years.

7. Will Smith (LAD)

• Games Played: 128 | At-Bats: 476 | Hits: 118 | Home Runs: 20 | RBIs: 75 | Batting Average: .248
• Slugging Percentage: .433 | OPS: .760

Will Smith continued to establish himself as one of the top catchers in the game. His 20 home runs and consistent offensive production were vital to the Los Angeles Dodgers’ success. With an OPS of .760, Smith was one of the more reliable hitters at the catcher position. His contributions on both sides of the ball make him one of the premier catchers in MLB.

8. Adley Rutschman (BAL)

• Games Played: 148 | At-Bats: 571 | Hits: 143 | Home Runs: 19 | RBIs: 79 | Batting Average: .250
• Slugging Percentage: .391 | OPS: .709

Adley Rutschman’s reputation continued to grow in 2024 as he became a cornerstone for the Baltimore Orioles. His strong defensive skills and improving offensive numbers (19 home runs and 79 RBIs) make him a well-rounded and valuable player. Though his OPS isn’t as high as some others on this list, Rutschman’s overall impact on the game, especially behind the plate, cannot be overstated.

9. Tyler Stephenson (CIN)

• Games Played: 138 | At-Bats: 457 | Hits: 118 | Home Runs: 19 | RBIs: 66 | Batting Average: .258
• Slugging Percentage: .444 | OPS: .782

Tyler Stephenson had an impressive 2024 season with the Cincinnati Reds, showcasing his power and consistency. With 19 home runs and a solid .258 batting average, he provided strong offensive support in a lineup filled with young talent. His defensive abilities also contributed to his solid ranking among the top catchers.

10. Kyle Higashioka (SD)

• Games Played: 84 | At-Bats: 246 | Hits: 54 | Home Runs: 17 | RBIs: 45 | Batting Average: .220
• Slugging Percentage: .476 | OPS: .739

Though Kyle Higashioka’s season was limited by injury, his 17 home runs in just 84 games show the type of power he brings to the table. His slugging percentage of .476 is an impressive number for a catcher, making him a potent option whenever healthy.

---

Conclusion: A Strong Class of Catchers

The 2024 MLB season was filled with incredible talent at the catcher position. Whether it's the power of Cal Raleigh or the leadership of Salvador Pérez, these players made a lasting impact on the season. While many of the top catchers had standout offensive seasons, their defensive skills behind the plate were just as important. As we look ahead to future seasons, expect these catchers to continue to be integral parts of their teams and the league.

If you want to stay updated on the latest MLB catcher rankings, make sure to follow baseball news and statistics as these athletes continue to impress season after season.

The Most Underrated MLB Catchers of 2025: Hidden Gems Behind the Plate

In the world of Major League Baseball, catchers are often the unsung heroes. While the spotlight is typically on the big sluggers and star pitchers, the men behind the plate are crucial to the team's success. In 2025, we’ve seen some catchers fly under the radar, despite their exceptional performances and contributions to their teams. These underrated catchers bring strong defense, leadership, and offensive power, but they haven’t received the recognition they deserve. Let’s take a deep dive into the most underrated catchers in MLB for 2025.

1. Tyler Stephenson – Cincinnati Reds

Tyler Stephenson, the Cincinnati Reds’ backstop, continues to impress with his blend of offensive and defensive skills. Despite being overshadowed by bigger names on the Reds roster, he’s been one of the most consistent and reliable catchers in recent seasons. Stephenson’s framing ability and excellent arm behind the plate make him a top-tier defender, and his bat has steadily improved year over year. In 2025, he’s maintained a solid .280 batting average and has been pivotal in stabilizing the Reds’ lineup. For a player who flies under the radar in a market that’s often overshadowed by other NL Central teams, Stephenson is one of the most underrated catchers in MLB today.

2. Danny Jansen – Toronto Blue Jays

While the Toronto Blue Jays have some of the brightest stars in the game, such as Vladimir Guerrero Jr. and Bo Bichette, Danny Jansen has quietly become one of the most underrated catchers in baseball. Jansen is known for his elite defensive skills, particularly his pitch-calling and game management abilities. Behind the plate, Jansen is a calming presence for the Blue Jays’ pitching staff, helping pitchers navigate tough situations with poise. In 2025, his bat has also come alive, posting an impressive .275 batting average with power numbers that rival many other starting catchers in the league. Jansen’s ability to balance defense and offense without the same level of attention as his teammates makes him a true hidden gem in the MLB.

3. Travis d'Arnaud – Atlanta Braves

Travis d’Arnaud’s career resurgence with the Atlanta Braves is a story of perseverance and talent. After some struggles with the New York Mets and other teams, d’Arnaud has found his stride in Atlanta, establishing himself as a consistent, dependable presence behind the plate. As of 2025, d’Arnaud is still one of the best defensive catchers in the league, with excellent pitch framing and a quick release on throws to second base. His bat, which has been quietly productive for years, has proven to be an asset, providing solid power and a consistent batting average. As the Braves continue to dominate the National League, d’Arnaud's contributions often go unnoticed, making him one of the most underrated catchers in the MLB.

4. Omar Narváez – New York Mets

Omar Narváez may not always grab headlines, but his all-around skills make him one of the most underrated catchers in MLB. Narváez is known for his ability to call a great game and his leadership behind the plate, guiding a pitching staff that has struggled with consistency in recent seasons. In 2025, Narváez has stepped up offensively, providing the Mets with consistent contact hitting from the bottom of the lineup. With a keen eye for walks and an understanding of how to work pitchers, Narváez has quietly been one of the better catchers in the league. His defensive acumen and ability to handle high-pressure situations have made him a key asset for the Mets, yet he still flies under the radar when it comes to national recognition.

5. Jacob Stallings – Miami Marlins

Jacob Stallings may not be a household name, but he’s one of the best-kept secrets in MLB in 2025. Playing for the Miami Marlins, Stallings often goes unnoticed in the media-heavy markets of bigger teams. However, his defensive prowess is undeniable. As one of the top pitch framers in the league, Stallings has been able to maximize his pitchers' effectiveness and keep games within reach. While his bat isn’t as flashy as some of his peers, he consistently puts together solid at-bats and plays a crucial role in the Marlins’ success. His leadership behind the plate is invaluable to a team that relies on strong pitching and defense, making Stallings one of the most underrated catchers in MLB today.

6. Alejandro Kirk – Toronto Blue Jays

Alejandro Kirk has quietly evolved into one of the most valuable catchers in baseball. The Toronto Blue Jays have plenty of star power, but Kirk’s bat and approach at the plate have flown under the radar. At 5’8”, Kirk is one of the more compact catchers in the MLB, yet his power and plate discipline belie his size. In 2025, Kirk has consistently posted an on-base percentage over .360, which is a significant achievement for a catcher. His ability to work pitchers and provide a steady presence in the lineup has kept the Blue Jays competitive. His underrated defensive abilities, such as pitch-blocking and game management, further solidify his value to the team.

7. Christian Vázquez – Minnesota Twins

Christian Vázquez is no stranger to being a dependable catcher, but his consistent excellence hasn’t always led to recognition. In 2025, Vázquez is quietly excelling for the Minnesota Twins, showcasing his elite defensive skills and ability to handle a pitching staff. His pitch-calling and game management are often overlooked, but they’re among the best in the league. Additionally, Vázquez is having one of his most productive offensive seasons in recent years, with a batting average hovering around .270. While he may not be the flashiest name in the American League, Vázquez’s value to the Twins cannot be overstated, making him another underrated catcher to watch in 2025.

Conclusion

While much of the spotlight in MLB often falls on high-profile position players, catchers are the unsung heroes who impact the game in ways that aren’t always visible in the box score. The catchers listed here—Tyler Stephenson, Danny Jansen, Travis d'Arnaud, Omar Narváez, Jacob Stallings, Alejandro Kirk, and Christian Vázquez—are all quietly excelling in their roles, providing critical defense, leadership, and offensive contributions to their respective teams. As we head into the remainder of the 2025 MLB season, these underrated catchers are worth keeping an eye on, as they continue to prove that behind the plate is where a lot of the game’s hidden talent truly lies.

By highlighting these undervalued players, it’s clear that there’s more to catching than just the flashy stats. The impact these players have on their teams—both offensively and defensively—deserves far more recognition. 

Contact Me

Privacy Policy